Claims will most often be based on a breach of moral duty to provide for the claimant(s). As a general principle, it can be said that for claims by children there are two classes:
- The first class is infant children who need obviously support and help if one of their parents dies and those adult children who by reason of sickness or a disability are unable to support themselves. In those cases, the Court will want to make sure that there is sufficient from the estate to satisfy the needs of such children during minority or for adults during their disability or incapacity.
- For adult children who are not disabled and are able to support themselves the position is different. It used to be the general principle that generosity started at home. Therefore, a testator leaving the assets to a charity was not favourably looked on by the Courts and provision was always to be made to the children first. However, that changed in the leading case of Williams v Aucutt [2000] 2 NZLR 479 which tempered any judicial inclination to be generous with the deceased’s estate for an adult child who had sufficient funds and was making an unmeritorious claim.
Adult independent children with their own means and assets (who have been left out of a will), can claim and sometimes there are awards in the range of 5-20% depending on the circumstances. This is because, in these cases, “support” can justify a separate claim, distinct from “maintenance”. Support may be understood in its wider sense of sustaining or providing comfort; however, where there is no economic need, any award is likely to be moderate.
The principle to be applied by the Court have included the following:
- “Proper maintenance and support” requires a broad approach that includes the need to recognise the child as a valued member of the family and other social and ethical factors. “Support” is a wider term than “maintenance” and is used in its wider dictionary sense of “sustaining, providing comfort”. A child’s path through life is supported not simply by financial provision to meet economic needs and contingencies but also by recognition of belonging to the family and of having been an important part of the overall life of the deceased.
- Assessing what provision will constitute proper support is a matter of judgment in all the circumstances of the particular case.
- The size of the estate and any other moral claims on the deceased’s bounty are relevant factors.
- In assessing whether the deceased has made appropriate provision for the claimant’s proper maintenance and support, and what would be required to remedy a failure, the court should do no more than the minimum to redress a testator’s breach of moral duty. Beyond that point the testator’s wishes should prevail, even if the individual Judge might, sitting in the testator’s armchair, have seen the matter differently. Testators are at liberty to do what they like with their assets and to treat their children differently or to benefit others once they have made such provisions as are necessary to discharge their moral duty to those entitled to bring claims under the Act.
- The Court’s power does not extend to rewriting a will because of a perception that it is unfair. Nor is disparity in the treatment of beneficiaries sufficient, in itself, to establish a claim.
Claims against an Estate can be very expensive for all participating parties. It is therefore desirable to avoid, if realistically possible, a claim. An anticipated claim may be addressed by either providing for the potential claimant some inheritance in the will, or a comprehensive note held with the will explaining why a person has been given no inheritance or a limited inheritance.
Another category of challenge to an estate is the Law Reform (Testamentary Promises) Act 1949 (TPA). This Act is unique to New Zealand.
It was created to fix a specific gap in common law where verbal or vague promises of inheritance for services rendered during a lifetime were unable to be effectively enforced under traditional contract law. Other countries achieve similar results through common law legal mechanisms such as proprietary estoppel, unjust enrichment or breach of contract.
The New Zealand TPA provides a statutory and flexible mechanism for making a claim. The Act allows implied or verbal promises to be considered by a Judge. The TPA has even recognised in some cases that services can even include companionship and support. The law, however, requires that “the service” must be linked to a promise to provide on death some reward, gift or payment, and in any companionship and support claim the service must go well beyond a normal friendship.
The important separate elements for the exercise of the jurisdiction under the TPA are that:
- The claimant must have rendered services to the deceased in his or her lifetime;
- The claimant must prove either that the deceased made an expressed promise for award for such services and to make some provision in the will or that such promise was implied. That communication to the claimant of a promise must have been communicated although that could be indirect as well as direct.
- The promise to reward for services must be a statement or representation of fact or intention. The promise itself need not be a specified amount. The remedy to enforce any promise must only be to the extent that the deceased failed to make the provision as promised and is to be limited to the amount that if the promise had been one for payment by the deceased during the lifetime such amount is only what is reasonable having regard to all the circumstances.
When making a will you should clarify with your lawyer any circumstances of some form of promise, whether verbal or implied, that may give rise to a claim on the will-maker’s death.
The information provided to the will-maker’s lawyer may clarify what should be in the will or allow the executors to refute a false claim. Again, a meaningful note should be made by the will-maker to accompany the will.





